How to Choose the Right AI Content Generator: Step-by-Step Guide

published on 17 February 2025

AI content generators can save you up to 70% of production time while improving consistency and SEO. But choosing the right one? That’s tricky. Here’s what you need to know:

  • Key Features to Look For:
    • Content types supported (e.g., blogs, social media, product descriptions).
    • Quality checks (plagiarism, readability, brand tone).
    • Different features of AI SEO tools (keyword research, SERP analysis, meta descriptions).
    • Integration ease with platforms like WordPress or Shopify.
  • Cost Breakdown:
    • Free tools like ChatGPT (basic) vs. paid options like Jasper AI ($39+/month).
    • Watch out for hidden fees (e.g., word overages, team seats).
  • Ease of Use:
    • Tools like ChatGPT are beginner-friendly, while Jasper AI offers advanced customization.
    • Trial periods (5 days for Jasper AI, Rytr) let you test before committing.
  • Quick Comparison:
Tool Best For Starting Cost Key Features
ChatGPT General assistance Free/$20/mo Simple interface, versatile use
Jasper AI Marketing content $39/mo SEO tools, 50+ tone options
Copy.ai E-commerce content Free/$36/mo Guided workflow, integrations
Writesonic High-volume content $13/mo Affordable, CMS integrations

Steps to Decide:

  1. Define your content needs (formats, frequency).
  2. Test tools for quality, customization, and SEO features.
  3. Compare costs and trial options.
  4. Ensure easy integration with your workflow.

Which AI Copywriter Performs the Best?

Step 1: List Your Content Requirements

Before jumping into comparing tools, it's important to first outline what your content needs are. This ensures you're picking a tool that aligns with your specific goals.

Content Types You Need

Think about the types of content that align with your marketing objectives. For example, blog posts are highly effective for B2B companies. According to a 2024 Content Marketing Institute report, 68% of B2B marketers view blog posts as their top format for generating leads.

Here’s a quick breakdown to prioritize content formats:

Content Category Production Priority
Long-form High for B2B
Short-form High for B2C
Technical Key for E-commerce
Marketing Copy Needed across industries

Content Production Schedule

Your publishing frequency should match your traffic goals. Research shows that companies publishing 16 or more blog posts a month generate 3.5 times more traffic. Don’t forget to account for seasonal trends when planning your schedule.

Must-Have Features

When choosing a tool, focus on features that will streamline your workflow. A 2024 Semrush survey revealed that 84% of marketers prioritise SEO integration when selecting content tools.

Key features to look for include:

  • Quality checks for plagiarism and readability
  • Brand voice customization to maintain consistency
  • Team collaboration tools for seamless teamwork
  • Multilingual support for global reach

Once you’ve nailed down these requirements, you’ll be ready to move on to evaluating tools in Step 2.

Step 2: Review Tool Features

A striking 82% of marketers say they work more efficiently when using AI writing tools with the right features.

Output Quality Standards

The quality of AI-generated content can vary widely. Tools like LongShot AI set themselves apart with features like built-in fact-checking and plagiarism detection. When evaluating output quality, pay attention to these critical factors:

Quality Metric What to Look For
Coherence Smooth flow and clear transitions between paragraphs
Accuracy Reliable facts and the latest information
Grammar Proper syntax and error-free writing
Originality Content that passes plagiarism checks and feels unique

Writing Style Options

AI tools differ in how much they let you customize the writing style. Jasper AI, for instance, offers more than 50 tone options, making it a favourite for marketers. Whether you need a formal tone, casual language, or industry-specific jargon, Jasper AI can adapt to your needs. This flexibility is especially useful for tasks like crafting product descriptions or technical content.

Jasper AI's versatility has earned it a 4.8/5 rating on G2 for quality and customization.

SEO Tools and Features

Tools like ContentShake AI bring SEO directly into the content creation process. Here are some must-have SEO features:

Feature Purpose Impact
Keyword Research Identifies key terms to target Boosts content relevance
SERP Analysis Reviews competing content Helps you outrank competitors
Meta Description Generator Creates search-friendly snippets Drives higher click-through rates
Content Structure Suggests effective headings Improves readability
Internal Linking Recommends related links Strengthens site navigation

Look for tools that work seamlessly with your existing SEO platforms. For example, Frase.io offers built-in keyword research and optimization tools that integrate with popular SEO software.

To find the best fit, try generating content on the same topic using different tools. Compare their SEO suggestions and overall quality to determine which one aligns best with your strategy while still producing content that feels natural and reader-focused. Once you've nailed down your top options, move on to evaluating costs in Step 3.

sbb-itb-c597ff7

Step 3: Compare Costs and Plans

Once you've nailed down the must-have features from Step 2, it's time to dive into the numbers. Here's how to evaluate the costs and plans of AI content generators.

Price Plan Comparison

AI content generator pricing can vary a lot depending on the features and capabilities. Here's a quick breakdown of how some popular tools stack up:

Tool Basic Plan Pro Plan Enterprise*
ChatGPT Free $20/month Custom
Jasper AI $39/month (50K words) $59/month (100K words) Custom
Copy.ai Free (Limited) $36/month Custom
Writesonic $13/month (200K words) $19/month Custom

*Enterprise plans typically require custom pricing.

For example, ChatGPT offers premium access for $20/month, while Writesonic stands out with high-volume capacity at competitive rates. Jasper AI adjusts its pricing based on word counts and added features.

Additional Costs

Keep in mind that there may be extra charges beyond the base subscription. Here's what to watch for:

Cost Type Description Typical Range
Overage Charges Fees for exceeding word limits $0.01–0.03/word
API Access For integrations with other tools $0.06 per 1K tokens
Team Seats Additional user access $25-50/user/month

Custom pricing is often the norm for enterprise-level tools that include perks like dedicated support or tailored model training.

Trial Period Options

Most tools let you test the waters with trial periods. Here's a snapshot of some trial options:

Tool Trial Period Limitations Best Testing Approach
Rytr 5 days 10K characters Test priority content types
Jasper AI 5 days 10K-word limit Test templates and tones

To get the most out of these trials:

  • Create the same content across different tools to see how they handle your brand’s voice (from Step 1).
  • Experiment with various formats like blog posts or social media content.
  • Check how responsive their support teams are and explore their resources.

Free trials are a great way to figure out which tool fits your needs before committing to a paid plan.

Step 4: Check Ease of Use and Integration

After analyzing costs in Step 3, it's time to evaluate how easily an AI content generator fits into your workflow. Did you know that 68% of marketers rank ease of use as a top factor when choosing AI writing tools?

Interface and Learning Time

Not all tools are created equal when it comes to usability. Here's a quick comparison of interfaces and how long it might take to get comfortable with them:

Tool Interface Type Learning Curve
ChatGPT Chat-based Simple and intuitive, great for beginners
Jasper AI Template-based Packed with features, customizable workspace
Copy.ai Guided workflow Smooth onboarding process

For instance, HubSpot's marketing team saw impressive results with Jasper AI, cutting content creation time by 62% and boosting blog output by 28% in just 90 days.

Platform Compatibility

Seamless integration with your existing tools is a must. Here's why it matters and some examples of tools to consider:

Integration Type Why It Matters Example Tools
CMS Integration Enables direct publishing WordPress, Drupal
E-commerce Simplifies product descriptions Shopify, WooCommerce
Marketing Tools Aligns campaigns effortlessly HubSpot, Mailchimp

Copy.ai stands out with integration capabilities for over 20 platforms, while Writesonic supports 12 major content management systems. Choosing a tool that aligns with your current tech stack can save time and reduce disruptions.

Team Features

Collaboration tools can make or break your team's productivity. Teams using collaborative AI platforms report 35% faster content production. Here are the must-have features:

  • Role Management: Assign specific access levels to team members.
  • Real-time Collaboration: Work together on content simultaneously.
  • Approval Workflows: Streamline seasonal content planning and execution, as mentioned in Step 1.

Look for tools that offer these features to keep your team on track and aligned with your production goals from earlier steps.

Conclusion: Choose Your Tool

Once you've worked through Steps 1-4, it's time to make your final decision. Companies that select AI tools tailored to their needs often see production speeds improve by 35-70%.

Selection Checklist

Compare your top priorities from Step 1 with the following evaluation points:

Evaluation Area Key Considerations
Content Output Quality, supported formats, tone variations
Cost Structure Feature access tiers
Usability Template availability
Support Training resources, response time

From Steps 2-3, we know that Copy.ai excels in creating e-commerce content and integrates with multiple platforms, while Jasper AI is ideal for long-form content and includes SEO-focused tools.

Next Steps

Get started with your chosen tool by following these practical tips used by industry leaders:

  • Use brand voice templates outlined in Step 1.
  • Train your team on the collaboration features highlighted in Step 4.
  • Regularly audit content quality based on metrics from Step 2.

FAQs

Is Jasper AI better than ChatGPT?

Jasper AI

The comparison depends on your specific needs, as these tools excel in different areas:

Feature Area Jasper AI ChatGPT
Primary Focus Marketing content creation General AI assistance
Key Strengths Marketing templates, brand voice settings Versatility, up-to-date knowledge through 2023

Jasper AI is tailored for:

  • Marketing content with pre-built templates
  • Maintaining brand voice consistency
  • SEO tools integrated with other platforms

ChatGPT stands out for:

  • General content creation
  • Technical tasks like coding or data analysis
  • Being a cost-effective option for broader needs

Your decision should align with your goals. Jasper is ideal for marketing-focused teams, while ChatGPT suits those needing a more versatile tool. Refer back to your requirements checklist to make the best choice.

Related Blog Posts

Read more